{"dimensions":[{"id":"token_discipline","points":20,"hard_fails":["No spacing scale","Multiple competing spacing systems (8pt plus random values)"],"score_guide":[{"max":5,"min":0,"criteria":"Tokens missing or inconsistent; ad-hoc values dominate"},{"max":10,"min":6,"criteria":"Partial tokens; inconsistent naming; gaps across categories"},{"max":15,"min":11,"criteria":"Most tokens present; minor inconsistencies; some ad-hoc"},{"max":20,"min":16,"criteria":"Complete token set; consistent naming; zero ad-hoc in spec"}]},{"id":"component_contracts","points":20,"hard_fails":["Missing button and input contracts","No defined states (hover/focus/disabled/error)"],"score_guide":[{"max":5,"min":0,"criteria":"Components listed without contracts"},{"max":10,"min":6,"criteria":"Some contracts; missing variants/states"},{"max":15,"min":11,"criteria":"Good contracts; minor gaps in states or anatomy"},{"max":20,"min":16,"criteria":"Full contracts; variants + states complete; implementation-ready"}]},{"id":"accessibility_semantics","points":15,"hard_fails":["No visible focus state requirements","Form patterns without labels"],"score_guide":[{"max":5,"min":0,"criteria":"No accessibility guidance"},{"max":10,"min":6,"criteria":"Partial; missing focus/labels/keyboard"},{"max":15,"min":11,"criteria":"Complete and actionable"}]},{"id":"layout_grid","points":15,"hard_fails":["No mobile behavior defined","No max content width for reading surfaces"],"score_guide":[{"max":5,"min":0,"criteria":"Vague layout guidance"},{"max":10,"min":6,"criteria":"Basic grid; missing content widths/rails"},{"max":15,"min":11,"criteria":"Fully specified grid and reading constraints"}]},{"id":"information_architecture","points":10,"hard_fails":["Allows marketing blocks inside pack templates or docs"],"score_guide":[{"max":3,"min":0,"criteria":"No IA rules"},{"max":7,"min":4,"criteria":"Partial; missing template constraints"},{"max":10,"min":8,"criteria":"Complete; enforceable rules"}]},{"id":"versioning_changelog","points":10,"hard_fails":["No changelog requirement for pack changes"],"score_guide":[{"max":3,"min":0,"criteria":"Absent"},{"max":7,"min":4,"criteria":"Present but vague"},{"max":10,"min":8,"criteria":"Explicit and enforceable"}]},{"id":"example_traceability","points":10,"hard_fails":["Examples contain ad-hoc values that violate token discipline"],"score_guide":[{"max":3,"min":0,"criteria":"No examples"},{"max":7,"min":4,"criteria":"Examples exist but not mapped or inconsistent"},{"max":10,"min":8,"criteria":"Mapped, copyable, consistent"}]}],"pass_score":85,"hard_fail_requires_zero":true}